High-Def Digest Forums

High-Def Digest Forums (https://forums.highdefdigest.com/)
-   Feedback (https://forums.highdefdigest.com/feedback-29/)
-   -   Biased reviews for HDDVD titles from High-Def Digest? (https://forums.highdefdigest.com/feedback/11569-biased-reviews-hddvd-titles-high-def-digest.html)

VC-1 07-10-2007 06:09 PM

Biased reviews for HDDVD titles from High-Def Digest?
 
How does the wedding date get a 1.5/5 stars for picture quality, and DVD authority gives it 4.5/5?

Likewise hometheaterspot gives the PQ a 4/5 stars.

There seems to be a pattern here and it seems to support the case that you're being biased against HDDVD.

I've noticed a trend lately, of lower than average scores for recent HDDVD releases from your site. If this is a problem with one reviewer I'd suggest you don't let him write reviews anymore.

I would like an explanation as you've lost all credability as far as your reviews of new titles go.

Links for the reviews I mentioned are here:

http://www.hometheaterspot.com/fusio...hp?tid/137782/

http://www.dvdauthority.com/reviews.asp?reviewID=5148

Detroit Tigers Fan 07-10-2007 06:35 PM

Yea!!! Stick it to the man...girly man that is...

GhostRider 07-10-2007 07:00 PM

Most likely because of the Blu bias from those other web pages.

illegalprelude 07-10-2007 08:34 PM

thats why I continue to support VHS, a proven and unbiased format

PIHB 07-10-2007 08:51 PM

all i have to say is shit happens and we got ourselves into the format war so we just have to check stuff out for ourselves, i know that i take the reviews here with a grain of salt

onavarr8 07-10-2007 09:21 PM

One thing I think this website could do, just an idea.....is to have more than one person review each movie separately, and then discuss afterwards and come to a conclusion for the review. I believe that would help a bit with accuracy as it will be based on more than one person's point of view....

maybe this website could hire an extra reviewer and try that or something..like that

Spideybat 07-10-2007 09:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by onavarr8 (Post 194937)
One thing I think this website could do, just an idea.....is to have more than one person review each movie separately, and then discuss afterwards and come to a conclusion for the review. I believe that would help a bit with accuracy as it will be based on more than one person's point of view....

maybe this website could hire an extra reviewer and try that or something..like that

We already have Peter and Ken. It's just a review. Not everyone is going to agree with it.

posters5 07-10-2007 10:11 PM

the video quality for "the wedding date" shouldn't be rated highly. it is indeed filled with a lot of video noise. it looks like there are a lot of mosquitoes in the background.

Nighthawk 07-10-2007 11:04 PM

Peter and Ken,

I for one, believe completely in your credibility. When the first Blu-ray movies surfaced, you guys smacked them down, and appropriately so. Just because a HD DVD fanboy can't accept the reviews of Universal's rushed to market, sloppy encoded newest releases does not negatively reflect on your judgment whatsoever.

It's unbelievable what tactics the HD DVD fanboys are resorting to these days. Talk about desperation...

eNoize 07-11-2007 12:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spideybat (Post 194959)
We already have Peter and Ken. It's just a review. Not everyone is going to agree with it.

Very well stated. Simply because you don't agree with a review does not mean its author has lost credibility. The reviewer has earned that position for a reason, and we should at least respect that much.

Quote:

Originally Posted by onavarr8 (Post 194937)
One thing I think this website could do, just an idea.....is to have more than one person review each movie separately, and then discuss afterwards and come to a conclusion for the review. I believe that would help a bit with accuracy as it will be based on more than one person's point of view....

maybe this website could hire an extra reviewer and try that or something..like that

Well, part of the reason for creating the Tier thread was with this intention -- a place to voice your opinion on the PQ of a particular title. If you don't agree with a review, state your assessment so that the film earns its proper placement.

Also, if you haven't seen the film, should you really complain about the review? I just watched it today, and take a wild guess of how it looked -- bad, plain and simple. After watching the film, I would question the reviews at "HomeTheaterSpot" and "DVD Authority." The PQ has its moments, albeit very few scenes, but not enough to impress. At times, it really looks more like SD DVD with colors looking dull, full of low level noise, and even color bleeding. I, for one, agree with this review over the other two.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:52 AM.