06-23-2014 06:54 PM #1Staff
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
Dolby Atmos Coming to Home Theaters
The immersive theater technology is finally heading to your living room.
http://www.highdefdigest.com/news/sh...theaters/16035Check out my award winning experimental short film Broken Records
06-23-2014 08:35 PM #2
Cool, so when I purchase 48 more speakers and run a half a mile of cable, I will be all set : )
Sounds like something cool, just more niche than anything due to its requirements.Keep Physical Media Alive, Just say NO to digital "ownership"
06-24-2014 07:19 AM #3
It's also too bad they aren't going to firmware update the TX-NR929 for ATMOS like they're doing with the 636, 737, and 838.The 3D King's Collection:
PSP Movies: 5
VCDs: 29 official releases
CD-I Movie: 1 LOL
06-24-2014 09:11 AM #4
Well, the 9.1 should give us front height, and the 11.1 should give us overhead. It seems that 13.1 should be minimal for full immersion. Truthfully, though, I would like to have floor speakers as well. May not be of a lot of use in anything I can think of other than space movies where you can have stuff going on below you, but still.
Sadly, the only one to announce prices is Oynko, and those prices are way out of my price range. I will have to wait for this to drop below $500 (perferably under $400) before I jump, so have to wait for the Sonys and Pioneers and Yamahas (not the elite lines, the regular consumer lines). So I guess a couple of years before price is right - I was just able to go 7.1 about two years ago.
06-24-2014 09:48 AM #5Member
- Join Date
- Jun 2008
I'm having a hard enough time figuring out how to do 7.1 in my new house. Damn open concept floor plans don't have enough walls...
06-24-2014 10:47 AM #6
Truthfully, though, I would like to have floor speakers as well. May not be of a lot of use in anything I can think of other than space movies where you can have stuff going on below you, but still.
06-24-2014 01:01 PM #7HDD Contributer
- Join Date
- Sep 2009
If the home implementation is anything like its theatrical sibling, Atmos tracks *should* be 9.1 cores... so the current 7.1 configuration (front three channels, two side channels, two rear) plus stereo overhead.
In a conventional cinema, the Atmos processor then adjusts itself to fit anywhere from the 9.1 up to 64.4. It'll be interesting to see how advanced the system is for the home, or perhaps it will be more akin to the next generation of Pro Logic.
However, given that most home cinemas are significantly more compact spaces compared to cinemas currently running Atmos, 9.1 should be plenty to recreate an Atmos experience in the home. The reason Atmos works so well is that it's able to take an entire wall (or array) of speakers that were once used only a 1 channel in a 5.1 or 7.1 setup, and divide them into individual discrete channels. In the home, if you listen to a 7.1 mix on a 7.1 set up, that one-to-one ratio is more akin to Atmos than a theatrical 7.1 experience.
06-24-2014 02:58 PM #8
True, but I am sure this would also depend on the size and shape of the room. My current apartment is small and square, and the sound is very different from my last apartment which was a wide rectangle, and that is very different from the house I lived in for several years that was long and rectangle. The idea that I could get the same sound in any of those settings would be nice.
The long rectangle room also had holes in the sound. I honestly thought of adding a couple more speakers on the sides to try to balance it out a bit (I didn't because I was not sure how I would drive them). Atmos would certainly take care of that.
I am sure someone will release a system that will do 17 channels or maybe even 21 (probably not more) for home for the few people who actually want it. Think people who have converted those huge basements into home theaters. Of course, this also brings the question of how far do you sit from your screen. In my current place, I could see 13 being good (although my neighbors might not agree). If I were back in my old house, I could certainly see 17 working for me
06-24-2014 07:39 PM #9HDD Contributer
- Join Date
- Sep 2009
Yeah, hopefully, home-cinema-Atmos will also allow customization so if you want to run 13/17/21 channels (assuming you have the amplification), it will be able to adapt to it.
Update: here's an idea of how it will work with Onkyo products.
06-24-2014 09:24 PM #10
06-25-2014 10:53 AM #11
Meanwhile, most consumers are moving to soundbars
06-25-2014 02:22 PM #12
06-25-2014 02:44 PM #13HDD Contributer
- Join Date
- Sep 2009
Correct, given what I've seen via the above Onkyo link, you technically don't have to purchase new special Atmos speakers IF you're prepared to move / mount one-to-two pairs on the ceiling. But if you don't want, or can't, install speakers in the ceiling, you have the option to buy Onkyo, or other brand, speakers that fire forwards and upwards, most likely with two inputs on each speaker.
OR you can buy these speaker modules that (presumably) sit atop speakers you currently own. If I jump into Atmos (I want to), I'll most likely need to get these given my apartment set up
The fun, and possibly frustration, of getting Atmos in the home seems only limited by the number of channels on your receiver:
With a 7.1 receiver, you can only do a "5.1.2" Atmos set up (Normal 5.1 plus stereo height).
With a 9.1 receiver, you can do up to a "5.1.4" or "7.1.2" Atmos set up (5.1 + four height, or 7.1 + stereo height)
And with an 11.1 receiver, you can do up to "Dolby's recommended" "7.1.4", or "9.1.2"
06-26-2014 11:29 PM #14
Totally forgot about this from the other thread. If special speakers aren't required I would certainly pick up a new receiver that supports ATMOS sometime. I can attest front height is useless, I tried it, never noticed it. Front width is supposed to be better, but the rooms characteristics wouldn't allow it.HT gear: Sony VPL-55ES 3D projector with 120in Hi Power screen, Klipsch RF-7 based 7.1 system, SVS subwoofer, Emotiva XPA5 5 channel amp, Pioneer 1120 reciever, Oppo BDP-93(region free), Xbox One, Playstation 4, , Xbox 360, Toshiba XA2
06-27-2014 01:41 PM #15
Great news. I've been waiting for this for a while.
Now to just figure out how to get those speakers in the ceiling. Also, I'm sure the studios are happy that they have a new excuse for making consumers double dip with the new Atmos-enabled versions of Blu-Rays they've already released.
Personally, I'll probably wait for the next physical media, which should also have Atmos support (and I'm also hoping HFR), so I can get more than just a sound upgrade when purchasing new media. Though, if that's too far away I might just give in and get Atmos enabled Blu-Rays.