Which Blu-ray releases look better on HD DVD?

**bruceames** · 10-12-2011 01:25 PM

Look forward to it, thanks.

**Plissken99** · 10-14-2011 03:57 AM

Well whoever said the Saw HD DVD looked better was wrong. I did a direct an A-B comparison between various shots. The Blu Ray reveals more fine object detail, and the HD DVD transfer is a bit too dark. The colors on the HD DVD might be a bit warmer, hard to tell with this movie. Tha dio on the HD DVD might be a tad better, as it boasts 7.1 audio, but 6.1 on the Blu Ray, but I'd doubt it's signifigent. $15, straight down the tubes.

**GizmoDVD** · 10-18-2011 10:48 PM

Originally Posted by Plissken99

Well whoever said the Saw HD DVD looked better was wrong. I did a direct an A-B comparison between various shots. The Blu Ray reveals more fine object detail, and the HD DVD transfer is a bit too dark. The colors on the HD DVD might be a bit warmer, hard to tell with this movie. Tha dio on the HD DVD might be a tad better, as it boasts 7.1 audio, but 6.1 on the Blu Ray, but I'd doubt it's signifigent. $15, straight down the tubes.

Resale value on Saw should be decent enough for an easy flip though.

**Hans Gruber** · 11-01-2011 01:27 AM

Hey plisken this is from page one on this topic about the german saw unrated is better pq than the us blu ray--

Originally Posted by REDBULL74

The German uncut Saw

import blows away the crappy US

release.

**Plissken99** · 11-01-2011 03:13 AM

Yeah thats the post that made me buy the German HD DVD, he was mistaken.

**esquire** · 04-22-2012 11:08 PM

So, should Universal's "The Deer Hunter" be added to the list based upon the reviews that are out there? Does anyone have any thoughts as to a comparison of the HD-DVD and the recent Universal release?

**bruceames** · 04-23-2012 12:33 AM

I would think it's a no brainer, given the level of DNR they coated on the Blu-ray version.

Thread: Which Blu-ray releases look better on HD DVD?

Thread Tools

Posting Permissions