Tier System for HD DVD

[Cochise]

Originally Posted by eNoize

Just watched Twister this weekend and think that the low Tier 2 placement is where I would have voted.

Yeah, my copy finally arrived from Amazon, and that's where I would place it as well. Been so long since I've watched it I forgot basically a pretty lame movie, IMHO.

Here's some ratings for Title Yet to be Ranked:

1408 - Director's Cut (Dutch Import) - I vote mid Tier 2, between Pitch Black & The Mummy

An American Haunting (Spanish Import) - Top Tier 3, between The Untouchables & Michael Clayton

Fantastic Four (German Import)
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (German Import) - Both upper Tier 2, between Balls of Fury & Blood Diamond

Green Street Hooligans (German Import) - Lower Tier 2, between Babel & Twister

Resident Evil (German Import) -
Resident Evil: Apocalypse (German Import) - Both mid Tier 3, between Top Gun & The Jackal

The Road to Rio/The Road to Bali - Upper Tier 4, between Under Siege & Friday Night Lights

Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life (German Import) - I'll let you know soon, I finally found a copy & have it on the way.

[vinnie97]

Army of Darkness: low tier 3 at best (below Sky Captain)

[eNoize]

My apologies to everyone for not updating the list. What with work, family, and my mod duties here, I'm on the internet maybe an hour at best. I'll try more to keep up on the list.

I've updated with all above requests and added a few of mine:

Freedom 3, 4 and 5, all three at top of Tier 1
Leaving Las Vegas, high Tier 4
Renaissance, low Tier 0
and last, but most definitely not least, La Vie en Rose (La Mome), mid-low Tier 2.

[Cochise]

Originally Posted by eNoize

My apologies to everyone for not updating the list. What with work, family, and my mod duties here, I'm on the internet maybe an hour at best. I'll try more to keep up on the list.

No rush, it's not like we have a ton of s yet to rate.

Here's some impressions of recent BBC U.K. Imports:

Robin Hood: The Complete Series One - Upper Tier 2, between Dreamgirls & The Departed. VC-1/DD5.1

Bleak House - Tier 2, under The Departed VC-1/LPCM 2.0

Becoming Jane - Mid Tier 2, between The Mummy & Dead Silence. VC-1 & DTS-HD 5.1

Twenty Thousand Streets Under the Sky (VC-1/PCM 2.0 Stereo), and Hotel Babylon, Season One (VC-1/PCM 2.0) lower Tier 2, between Pride and Prejudice & The Good Shepherd.

[eNoize]

list updated.

thanks, Cochise.

[Cochise]

And Torchwood Season One BBC UK Import - upper Tier 1, between Planet Earth & Galapagos. Exceellent VC-1 video and DTS-HD High Resolution audio. Entertaining series as well.

[vinnie97]

Zodiac ought to be upped a notch.

[eNoize]

Sorry for taking so long, but for what it's worth, the list is updated.

[JackHunt]

Finally got around to watching The Getaway (1972) and forgot how much I loved that movie.

Tier 3 - mid. Great Flick...decent transfer.

[drgonzo369]

HDs I own by tiers

Tier 0 - 9
Tier 1 - 7
Tier 2 - 10
Tier 3 - 7
Tier 4 - 2
Tier 5 - 1

HD dvds not rated by Tiers yet - 3

Any Idea of when the following will be ranked?

Anchorman
Appleseed Ex Machina
Justice League New Frontier

[JackHunt]

Originally Posted by drgonzo369

HDs I own by tiers

Any Idea of when the following will be ranked?

Anchorman
Appleseed Ex Machina
Justice League New Frontier

I actually own Anchorman and it looks great. I'd say upper Tier 2. Would not hesitate on a double dip for that one.

As for the other titles, I'm guessing since the last rating post, besides mine, was on August 7... it's gonna be a while.