'Knocked Up' - High-Def Digest review

[jed]

Just posted Peter's review of 'Knocked Up.' Overall, he says this one's quite strong. Although he says neither the video nor the audio are exceptional, both are above average, and he thoroughly enjoyed the disc's nice set of extras.

Full review here:
http://hddvd.highdefdigest.com/988/knockedup.html

[DrAndonuts]

Hmm, I'm taking this review with a huge grain of salt, in regards to the extras. Considering every other review I've read, for both the HD and DVD, have given the extras at least a 9/10, I find it hard to swallow the rating this reviewer gave them. That, and the fact that The 40-Year-Old Virgin DVD and HD had a brilliant set of extras leave me skeptical.

[TheRescue]

I'm just disappointed to see a 3.5 star video rating. I was hoping for a 5.

[Master X]

Originally Posted by TheRescue

I'm just disappointed to see a 3.5 star video rating. I was hoping for a 5.

Atleast a 4

[MidnightWatcher]

This is a fantastic film. Definitely worth the purchase.

[Kurri]

Originally Posted by TheRescue

I'm just disappointed to see a 3.5 star video rating. I was hoping for a 5.

at least 4

i think 5 is a stretch from a "critic" but this review of 3.5 i dissapointing

[Maxx_75]

My wife and I were pretty interested in this movie even though I lean Blu but I don't buy combos and I would have liked to have a lossless track.

O well.... rent it from LIVE or ON Demand.

[tru2blu]

Disappointing At least give it High Def audio

[diabolo]

Originally Posted by tru2blu

Disappointing At least give it High Def audio

Knocked Up

PQ
AQ

http://forums.highdefdigest.com/show...3&postcount=34

Originally Posted by tru2blu

I'll still get this. I really like the movie. It has to be better than my laserdic version
And the artwork does it for me

Cheers

Dracula
PQ
AQ

Hmm

[diabolo]

Btw i already pre-ordered Knocked Up

[M@tt]

I really think this needed to be a two disc set, the whole idea of these combo releases is that J6P will pay a little more to future proof their purchase but why spend more money for less content than the two disc DVD? In a perfect world, I'd have liked some HD featurettes on the second disc but even if they just put the second DVD bundled in it would have been an improvement.

[shawnmos]

Originally Posted by Maxx_75

My wife and I were pretty interested in this movie even though I lean Blu but I don't buy combos and I would have liked to have a lossless track.

O well.... rent it from LIVE or ON Demand.

You can get it from FYE for $20. I'd post a link but I can't since I have less than 10 posts.

[ben1080p]

interesting review...disspapointed about the 3.5 PQ but still getting it!

[onavarr8]

I was also expecting at least a 4.5 for PQ cuz someone on here said it looked just as good as Hot Fuzz which got my hopes up.....but 3.5..whatever im still getting it aswell

[leons26]

I have to say that it will be impossible for me to be HD DVD exclusive. I know that it messes up the balance and war this and war that. It is just that I have also read that "Superbad" will be out on Blu Ray. To me "40 year old virgin", "Knocked Up", and "Superbad" are 3 movies that have to be all had to make me happy. Think about it. It covers all most age ranges; from teens to mature adults. I wouldn't be surprised if they had a golden years comedy up thier sleeves. I will be first in line to buy "Knocked Up" and who knows what the holiday season will bring.