Quote:
Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
No, that would mean admitting that the reviewer here would need to edit his review since he claimed the Blu-ray is clearly "superior". That would mean lowering the scores of the BD since the HD DVD has a better picture, but that won't happen. Just like when Heroes Season 1 BD drops 3 features that the HD DVD had and it still maintains the same score as the HD DVD, but up the AQ goes higher for BD since it now includes a DTS MA track. Color me confused.
I should add that every reviewer is entitled to their opinions - so he may have thought the BD looked better. Could have been his TV, BD players vs HD DVD player etc. But the pictures above show the HD DVD to clearly be better, have higher peaks, and *gasp* have an additional 5GB of space.
Me? I kept by $5 HD DVD  |
Ummm. The reviewer at HTF is Robert Harris... Ever heard of him? He is the guy that remastered The Godfather Trilogy for Paramount and has lobbied the studios against using excessive DNR and EE.
Very odd.. Something is off here..
Very frustrating nonetheless.. I will keep my HD DVD version even though the BD has lossless. Uggh...